Bottom bracket removal tips

retroJIM

Orange 🍊 Fan
Feedback
View
Does anyone have any tips?

I've used loads of penetrating fluid and I've got a 450mm breaker bar and it still won't budge.:-(

Is heat or cold worth a go? Or do I need to try and drill it out?

Cheers,

Jim
 

Attachments

  • IMG_20201009_203210_resize_86.webp
    IMG_20201009_203210_resize_86.webp
    161.9 KB · Views: 643
Re:

I’ve never failed with my method and I buy and strip loads of bikes which are neglected.

Use a QR skewer to hold the BB tool in place , and then put the tool in a vice. Then turn the frame. It never fails.
 
Re:

Jim - small thing - are you turning it the right way? You may be on top of it but it’s an easy mistake....
 
Re:

I’ve got a few of really bad ones out by hammering the spindle from the drive side through to the non drive side and then hacksawed the stuck cups in about 4 places just enough not to damage the threads on the frame. Then the cups should ‘peel’ out with a bit of persuasion. I’d only do this as a last resort though.
 
Re:

Thanks for all the replies.

Turning the frame with the tool in a vice is a good idea but I need a fixed work bench to do that, also my bb tool is round so can't easily be clamped in a vice.

Pretty certain I'm going the right way (clockwise on the drive side - so towards the chainstay in my photo?)

Will try again tomorrow :-)
 
Re:

yep...

from the aptly named thread 'which way do you undo a bottom bracket?':
The common threading for bottom bracket shells is called “English.” The left-side cup is a right-hand thread direction, which tightens clockwise and removes counterclockwise. The right-side (drive-side) thread is a left-hand thread, which tightens counterclockwise and loosen clockwise.

I've never been defeated, but by God, some have put up a right struggle...
 
Easy way to remember, pedals tighten to the front of the bike, bottom brackets to the rear.
 
Re:

Success :-D

Thanks for the help. In the end brute force did the trick.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_20201010_091441_resize_20.webp
    IMG_20201010_091441_resize_20.webp
    67.8 KB · Views: 549
  • IMG_20201010_091430_resize_50.webp
    IMG_20201010_091430_resize_50.webp
    97.3 KB · Views: 549
Re:

hmm ... well done for hauling on that and getting it to move. Not a trace of anti seize on that, and typical problem of drain hole in BB being absent or blocked. It's a two-minute job to poke out the drain hole but seldom done. Mental note - time to do it on all the steel bikes....

You seem to have a nice big drain hole in the BB, but check that it hasn't got a big lip around it on the inside from when it was drilled. They often do. That prevents them from working as a drain hole, and gathers cr+p around it, then blocks it. I chamfer slightly the inside and outside, then they then work as a drain hole and don't gather rubbish either from the inside or the outside. And spray a load of silicon inside the BB shell, this helps bead the water so it forms heavy droplets that descend to the drain hole and out....

Cleaning the threads can be easy if you use a small wire brush and angle pick, and then a toothbrush and then run a steel cup from the distant past in and out, inching it in and turning it back and then brushing all the crud out. I have some with no lip which means I can run them right in, cleaning the thread deeply.

Great job. Copper anti-seize on the one which goes back in, and a clean drain hole....
 
Back
Top